Breaking Barriers: 5 Unique Challenges for Black Women Applying to Fellowships

Feb 05, 2025

A woman holding a tennis racquet on top of a tennis court — Photo by Jadon Johnson on Unsplash

Introduction

Academic fellowships are prestigious opportunities that provide funding, mentorship, and access to elite networks. However, for Black women, the path to securing these opportunities can be riddled with systemic and cultural challenges that often go unaddressed. While these fellowships promise equity and access, the structural barriers faced by Black women applicants highlight the need for targeted support and reform. This blog explores five unique challenges Black women encounter when applying for fellowships and offers insights into overcoming them.

1. Limited Representation in Academia

One of the most significant challenges Black women face is the lack of representation in academia. According to the National Science Foundation (NSF), Black women make up less than 3% of full-time faculty in higher education. This scarcity of role models and mentors directly impacts the fellowship application process.

Mentors play a critical role in guiding fellowship applicants by providing feedback on essays, recommendation letters, and overall strategy. Without mentors who share similar lived experiences, Black women may struggle to navigate the nuances of competitive applications. Furthermore, the absence of visible examples of success can make the process feel isolating and discourage Black women from even applying.

Actionable Insight

Seek out affinity groups like Black Women PhDs or academic associations that focus on diversity. Organizations like the new M2M Sistah Scholars Community provides mentorship programs and workshops tailored to underrepresented groups.

2. Implicit Bias in Selection Committees

Implicit bias remains a pervasive issue within academia, influencing decisions made by fellowship selection committees. Studies show that bias—whether related to race, gender, or socioeconomic background—can skew how applications are evaluated.

Black women are often evaluated through stereotypes that question their competence, ambition, or fit within elite academic spaces. This bias can manifest in subtle ways, such as an undervaluation of non-traditional research topics or community-focused work, both of which are often central to Black women’s academic pursuits.

Actionable Insight

When possible, highlight the broader societal impact of your research or work. Articulating how your goals align with the fellowship’s mission can help mitigate biases by framing your application in terms of shared values.
Share Misogynoir2Mishpat’s Substack

3. Balancing Multiple Responsibilities

Black women often juggle multiple responsibilities that make the time-intensive fellowship application process even more daunting. Family obligations, financial pressures, and professional commitments frequently compete for their attention.

Cultural expectations may also play a role. Black women are more likely to assume caregiving roles for extended family members, which can limit their availability to engage in time-consuming tasks like writing personal statements or preparing for interviews. This added burden often puts them at a disadvantage compared to applicants who have fewer external pressures.

Actionable Insight

Develop a clear application timeline that breaks the process into manageable steps. Utilize tools like Trello or Notion to track progress, and seek accountability partners within your network.

4. Financial Barriers

While many fellowships offer financial support, the costs associated with applying can be prohibitive for Black women, who are more likely to face systemic financial inequities. Application fees, standardized test costs, and travel expenses for interviews or conferences can create significant barriers.

Additionally, the opportunity cost of dedicating time to fellowship applications instead of paid work can be substantial. For applicants already managing student loans or other financial obligations, the upfront costs may deter them from applying altogether.

Actionable Insight

Look for fellowships that waive application fees for applicants from underrepresented backgrounds. Groups like the Sistah Scholars community and the Misogynoir to Mishpat Research Network, and similar platforms, provide curated lists of fellowships with no application fees.

5. Lack of Tailored Resources

Most fellowship preparation resources are designed with a one-size-fits-all approach, failing to address the specific challenges Black women face. Generic advice often overlooks the unique experiences, cultural contexts, and structural hurdles that shape their academic and professional journeys.

For instance, many Black women focus their research or professional work on issues related to race, equity, or social justice—topics that may not align with traditional fellowship priorities. Without resources that validate and support these perspectives, Black women may feel pressured to conform their applications to fit the mold.

Actionable Insight

Seek out programs explicitly designed for underrepresented groups in academia. For example, the Ford Foundation Fellowship emphasizes diversity and supports scholars whose work focuses on social justice.

Strategies to Overcome Challenges

While these challenges are significant, there are actionable steps Black women can take to navigate the fellowship application process effectively.

Build a Support Network
- Join academic associations or online communities for Black women scholars, such as Sistah Scholars or the African American Women in Higher Education network. These platforms provide mentorship, peer support, and access to resources.
Leverage Institutional Resources
- Many universities have offices dedicated to diversity and inclusion or fellowship advising. Don’t hesitate to seek their support for application reviews or interview preparation.
  Share
Advocate for Yourself
- Clearly articulate your accomplishments and the unique perspectives you bring to the table. Use your personal statement to tell a compelling story that highlights your resilience and impact.
Engage Allies
- Identify faculty members or colleagues who can advocate for you by writing strong recommendation letters or providing strategic advice.
Educate Yourself on Bias
- Understanding how implicit bias operates can help you craft an application that anticipates and counters potential stereotypes.

Looking Ahead: Transforming the System

Addressing these challenges requires systemic change within academia and beyond. Fellowship programs must take proactive steps to combat bias, such as implementing blind application reviews or offering implicit bias training for selection committees. Institutions should also invest in programs that provide mentorship and financial support for underrepresented applicants.

Black women have always been trailblazers in academia, breaking barriers and creating pathways for others to follow. By acknowledging the unique challenges they face and advocating for systemic reform, we can ensure that more Black women have access to the transformative opportunities fellowships provide.

Share Misogynoir2Mishpat’s Substack

Conclusion

The journey to securing fellowships as a Black woman in religious studies is marked by unique challenges and systemic barriers. However, it is a journey that can be navigated successfully with the right support, preparation, and persistence. This article explored the primary hurdles we face.

Part II of this article will dive deeper into the data behind these disparities and present strategies to overcome them. Additionally, for those looking to connect with others who share their experiences, the new Sistah Scholars Community is dedicated to supporting Black women religious scholars in achieving success in fellowship applications through practical tools, mentorship, and coaching.

Misogynoir2Mishpat’s Substack

Breaking Barriers: 5 Unique Challenges for Black Women Applying to Fellowships

Discussion about this post